The squat is one of the most fundamental and effective exercises in fitness. Yet, over the years, countless "how-to" guides and expert opinions have emerged, claiming to show the correct way to perform a squat. These guides often stress specific body positions and movement patterns, asserting that there is one optimal way to squat for everyone. However, emerging research in biomechanics, anatomy, and movement science suggests that this pursuit of a universal squat technique is misguided. There is no single "perfect" squat form that applies to everyone. In fact, insisting on a standardized squat technique may not only limit performance but could also increase the risk of injury.

The Biomechanics of Squatting: One Size Does Not Fit All

The mechanics of squatting depend on various factors, including bone structure, muscle length, joint mobility, and limb proportions. These factors differ significantly from one person to another, making a single squat technique ineffective or even harmful for some individuals.

1. Anatomical Variation in Hip Structure

One of the most important determinants of squat form is the anatomy of the hip joint. The hip is a ball-and-socket joint, where the femoral head (ball) fits into the acetabulum (socket) of the pelvis. The shape and orientation of this joint can vary greatly between individuals, influencing the range of motion and comfort during a squat.

For example:

• Femoral Neck Angle: The angle between the femoral shaft and the neck of the femur can affect how deep a person can squat comfortably. Some people have a steeper angle, which allows for deeper squats, while others have a more shallow angle, limiting their squat depth.
• Acetabular Orientation: The angle and depth of the socket in the pelvis also vary. Some people have shallow, forward-facing sockets      that allow greater mobility, while others have deeper sockets that restrict movement.

These anatomical differences mean that two people with different hip structures will squat differently. Forcing both to adhere to the same form (such as knees not passing the toes or feet pointed directly forward) can lead to discomfort or injury, as one person may have to compromise their natural range of motion to fit the “ideal” form.

2. Limb Proportions and Torso Length

Another key factor in squatting mechanics is individual limb length and body proportions. The length of the femur (thigh bone), tibia (shin bone), and torso affects how a person’s body moves during a squat.

• Long Femurs: People with relatively long femurs compared to their torso will need to lean their upper body forward more to maintain balance during a squat. This often gives the appearance of a "poor" squat form, but it is simply an adaptation to their body structure. Trying to keep an upright torso in such cases can place undue stress on the lower back.
• Short Femurs, Long Torso: Individuals with shorter femurs and a longer torso, on the other hand, may find it easier to maintain a more vertical posture during a squat.

Given these differences, prescribing a universal squat form that insists on a vertical torso or specific knee position doesn't account for variations in body proportions. Instead, individuals should experiment with different foot placements and torso angles to find what works best for their unique structure.

3. Ankle Mobility and Squat Depth

Ankle mobility is another critical factor that influences squat performance. Limited dorsiflexion (the ability to bend the ankle so that the top of the foot moves toward the shin) can restrict how far forward the knees can travel during a squat. This limitation forces the body to compensate in other areas, such as by leaning forward or shifting weight to the heels, which can affect balance and increase strain on the lower back.

While some trainers emphasize keeping the heels on the ground and the knees from moving past the toes, these guidelines are based on general principles that don’t apply universally. A person with limited ankle mobility may find it difficult to squat deeply without their heels rising or their knees moving forward. In such cases, modifications like elevating the heels with a small plate or using a wider stance can help accommodate mobility limitations and improve squat depth without compromising form.

The Myth of the "Knees Over Toes" Rule

One of the most enduring myths in squat form is the idea that the knees should never travel past the toes during a squat. This belief, rooted in older fitness advice, suggests that allowing the knees to extend beyond the toes places excessive strain on the knee joints and increases the risk of injury. However, modern biomechanical research has debunked this notion.

A 2003 study published in the journal Clinical Biomechanics examined the effects of knee position on joint stress during squats. The researchers found that restricting forward knee movement reduced stress on the knees but significantly increased the stress on the hips and lower back . Essentially, preventing the knees from moving past the toes shifts the load to other parts of the body, which can lead to injury in the lower back or hips for some individuals.

For people with adequate ankle and knee mobility, allowing the knees to travel past the toes is a natural part of the squatting movement and can help distribute the load more evenly across the lower body. The key is to ensure that the knees are tracking in line with the feet and that the movement feels controlled and comfortable.

The Importance of Individualized Squat Technique

Rather than enforcing a rigid, one-size-fits-all squat technique, it’s essential to recognize the individual nature of squatting mechanics. The best squat form for one person may be completely different from what works for someone else, based on their unique anatomy, mobility, and proportions.

Practical Tips for Finding Your Optimal Squat Form:

1. Experiment with Foot Position: Some people may need to squat with their feet turned out slightly, while others can keep them parallel. A wider stance may be more comfortable for individuals with limited hip mobility or longer legs.
2. Vary Your Depth: There is no universal squat depth that applies to everyone. Some individuals can squat deeply while maintaining proper form, while others may be more comfortable stopping at parallel. Squat depth should be based on individual mobility and comfort rather than external standards.
3. Adjust Torso Angle: Your torso doesn’t have to remain perfectly upright during a squat. Leaning forward slightly is a natural adaptation, especially for those with long femurs or limited ankle mobility. Focus on maintaining a neutral spine rather than forcing your torso into an upright position.
4. Use Props If Necessary: If you have limited ankle or hip mobility, consider using props like heel elevation plates or boxes to adjust your squat form. These tools can help you achieve better depth and maintain balance without compromising your natural movement pattern.
5. Listen to Your Body: The most important principle in squatting is to listen to your body. If a particular movement pattern feels uncomfortable or painful, it’s a sign that something isn’t right for your individual structure. Adjust your form until you find a position that feels natural and safe.

Embracing Individuality in Squatting

The idea that there is a single "correct" way to squat is a myth. Human bodies vary greatly in terms of anatomy, mobility, and proportions, which means that squat form should be personalized, not standardized. Biomechanics research shows that trying to force everyone into the same squat technique can do more harm than good, leading to discomfort, imbalances, and even injury.

Instead, the focus should be on discovering the squat form that works best for your individual body. By embracing the natural variations in hip structure, limb proportions, and mobility, you can squat safely and effectively, unlocking the full benefits of this fundamental exercise.

References:

1. Fry, A. C., Smith, J. C., & Schilling, B. K. (2003). Effect of knee position on hip and knee torques during the barbell squat. Journal of Strength and Conditioning Research, 17(4), 629-633.
2. Kritz, M., Cronin, J., & Hume, P. (2009). The Body’s Acute Response to Barbell Squat Exercise: An Overview. Journal of Strength and Conditioning Research, 23(7), 2060-2074.
3. Escamilla, R. F. (2001). Knee biomechanics of the dynamic squat exercise. Medicine and Science in Sports and Exercise, 33(1), 127-141.
4. Grasso, R., Zago, M., & Lacquaniti, F. (2000). Interactions between posture and locomotion: Motor patterns in humans walking with bent posture versus erect posture. Journal of Neurophysiology, 83(1), 288-300.
5. Rippetoe, M., & Kilgore, L. (2006). Starting Strength: Basic Barbell Training (2nd ed.). The Aasgaard Company.
6. Lorenzetti, S., Ostermann, M., Zeidler, F., Zimmer, P., Jentsch, L., List, R., & Schellenberg, F. (2018). How to Squat: Biomechanics of the Squat Varieties. Orthopedic Journal of Sports Medicine, 6(10), 1-11.
7. Neitzel, J. A., & Davies, G. J. (2000). The benefits and controversy of the parallel squat in strength training and rehabilitation. Strength      and Conditioning Journal, 22(4), 30-37.

‍